Identification and Prioritization of Environmental Criteria of Sustainable Outsourcing Model in Fajr Jam Gas Refining Company with Analytic Hierarchy Process Method

Document Type : Original Article


1 Department of Management, Kish International Branch, Islamic Azad University, Kish Island, Iran

2 Department of Management, Tehran Sciences and Researches Azad University, Tehran, Iran

3 Department of Accounting, Khatam University, Tehran, Iran


The purpose of this paper is to identify and prioritize environmental criteria of sustainable outsourcing model in Fajr Jam Gas refining company with hierarchical analysis procedure method. In order to identify environmental criteria, the identified strategic goals of the model are categorized in the most four aspects of the balanced scorecard and three dimensions of economic, social and environmental sustainability. to determine the importance of each environmental criteria in terms of four groups of experts (members of the outsourcing committee, managers, supervisors and experts in the company) are reported using Analytic Hierarchy Process (AHP) method and the results of research are reported through EXPERT CHOICE software. The findings indicated that in order to design sustainable outsourcing model using a balanced scorecard, seven strategic objectives in environmental dimension had to be considered two objectives in learning and growth aspect, two objectives in internal business processes aspect, two objectives in customer satisfaction aspect and a strategic environmental objective in financial performance aspect were identified. Finally, using a paired comparisons questionnaire, the importance of each strategic objective was calculated and prioritized.


  1. Mahdavi-Adeli, Mohammad-Hosein; Rouhollah, Nazari, (2015). Economic, energy and environmental growth: analysis of E3 Model in Iran. Quantitative Economics Quarterly (former economic analysis). volume 11, No. 1, spring 2014, pp. 19-40.
  2. Taheri-Safar, Marjan, Abolhasani, Leila, Shahnoushi-Foroushani, Naser (2015). Determination of evaluation indicators of economic, social and environmental sustainability of large dams. Third National Conference on Environmental and Agricultural Researches in Iran. July 2015.
  3. Mehregan, Mohammad-Reza; Salami, Hadi; Khajeh, Mostafa, (2010). Presenting a multi-criteria decision-making model for outsourcing business processes using network analysis technique, Management of change and development. No. 6, pp. 17-30.
  4. Gulzhanat, T. (2012)., Advantages and disadvantages of outsourcing: analysis of outsourcing practices of Kazakhstan banks, international Conference on Leadership, Technology and Innovation Management , Procedia - Social and Behavioral Sciences 41: 188 – 195.
  5. Fabio, D, F,. Petrillo, A,. & Autorino, C. (2015). Development of a Framework for Sustainable Outsourcing: Analytic Balanced Scorecard Method (A-BSC)).
  6. Mahdavi-Mazdeh, Mohammad; Lotfollah-Hamedani, Mohammad-Reza, (2012). Analysis of key success factors in strategic outsourcing to identify optimum methodology, Eighth International Industrial Engineering Conference. Tehran: Iran Industrial Engineering Association, Amirkabir University of Technology.
  7. Alem-Tabriz, Akbar; Shayesteh, Roya (2011). Evaluation and Prioritization of outsourcing the working processes of taxation in tax administration using fuzzy TOPSIS approach, Tax Research Journal, No. 10 (58), spring and summer 2011.
  8. Karimi-Govareshki, Mohammad-Hosein, Elyasi, Mahdi; Abedi-Jouzam, Reza, (2012). A pattern for production outsourcing decisions in a governmental organization. Scientific Research Journal of Innovation Management, First year, No. 2, winter 2012, pp. 83-106.
  9. Cheshmberah, Mohsen; Mortazavi, Mohsen (2010). Effective outsourcing management, Mehrban Book Institute, Publication: Tehran, second edition.
  10. Ahmadian, Majid, Abdoli, Ghahraman; Jabal-Ameli, Farkhondeh; Shabanakh, Mahmoud; Khorasani, Seyyed-Adel, (2017). Environmental degradation effect on economic growth (proofs from 32 developing countries), Economic Growth and Development Researches, Seventh year, No. 27, pp. 17-27.
  11. Azadnia, Mohammad; Zahedi, Shams-ol-Sadat; Mojeddin, Abdolreza; Pourabedi, Mohammad-Reza, (2017). The effective pattern of native search engine plan on sustainable development based on sustainability indicators. Technology Development Quarterly, Thirteenth year, No. 52.
  12. Rajesh, K. S.,  Murty, H.R., Gupta, S.K., Dikshit,  A.K.. (2012). An overview of sustainability assessment methodologies. Ecological Indicators, Volume 9, Issue 2, March 2009, Pages 189-212
  13. Opresnik, D,. & marco, T. (2015). Concept of sustainability in operation management, The 22nd CIRP Conference on Life Cycle Engineering, Procedia CIRP29: 532 – 537.
  14. Kargar-Deh-Bidi, Navid; Ismaili, Abdolkarim (2017). Evaluation of economic factors affecting environmental pollution in Iran. Agricultural Economic Research, volume 9, No. 4, pp. 85 - 108.
  15. Cardinaels, E., Paula, M, G,. & Veen-Dirks, V. (2010). Financial versus non-financial information: The impact of information organization and presentation in a Balanced Scorecard, Accounting Organizations and Society,Vol 35: 565–578
  16. Kaplan, Robert S.; David P., Norton, (2015). Strategy maps: converting intangible assets to tangible outcomes, monitored and translated by: Hossein Akbari, Masoud Soltani and Amir Maleki. Scientific editor of Abutaleb Gerehei. Publication: Ariana Ghalam, Fifth edition, 2015.
  17. Leontina, B,. & Sorin, B. (2011). Balanced Scorecard – Sustainable Development Tool, Analele Stiintifice ale Universitatii, Alexandru Ioan Cuza, din Iasi - Stiinte Economice, Alexandru Ioan Cuza University, Faculty of Economics and Business Administration, vol. 2011: 19-27
  18. Ghodsipour, Hasan (2016). Analytical Hierarchy Process (AHP), Publication: Amirkabir University of Technology (Tehran Polytechnic), Twelfth edition.
  19. Azami, Somayeh; Almasi, Mojtaba; Golmohammadi, Afsaneh (2017). Environmental regulations effect on industrial competitiveness: Proofs from the industrial plants of America, England and Canada. Economic Modeling Quarterly. Eleventh year, No. 3 (39), p. 119-139.
  20. Mirzaei, A,. Esfanjari-Kenari, A.,  Reza; Mahmoudi, Abolfazl; Shabanzadeh, Mahdi, (2016). Shadow economy and its role in controlling environmental damages in MENA countries. Scientific Research Quarterly Journal, Economic Growth and Development Researches, Sixth year, No. 24, pp. 107-118.
  21. Salatin, Parvaneh, Eslamboulchi, Sahar (2016). Environmental quality effect on health economics in group of selected countries, Environmental Science and Technology, Eighteenth volume, No. 1, spring 2016.
  22. Jafari-Samimi, Ahmad; Ahmadpour, Seyyed-Mohioddin, (2011). Analysis of relationship between environmental performance index and economic growth in developed countries, Quarterly Journal of Energy and Environmental Economics, First year, winter 2011, pp. 55- 72.
  23. Apergis, Nicholas. (2016).  Kuznets curves: New evidence on both panel and country-level CO2 emissions. Energy Economics, Elsevier, vol. 54(C), pages 263-271.